When Is Anger a Problem? Self-Assessment (PDF, Word): Life Areas, Costs

Plenty of adults start anger management unsure that their anger is the real trouble, and some come only because an employer, a court or a partner sent them. When is anger a problem, and is it theirs? This self-assessment hands that question to the client, to answer in their own ratings, before any skills work begins.

The client sees the pattern of their anger and what it has cost them in their own marks, and leaves the session with reasons to change that are theirs. You get a starting point to come back to at the end of treatment, and a place to begin the skills work.

When Is Anger a Problem? Life Areas and Reasons to Change

Blank anger self-assessment, page 1 with how often, how strong and how long, and how anger comes out in three columns
Blank Life Areas page of the anger self-assessment with four areas, each rated Not at all to Very much with a box
Blank second Life Areas page of the anger self-assessment, from mood and alcohol to money, the law and safety
Blank Reasons to Change page of the anger self-assessment with costs, an importance rating and a first step
Download

At a glance

  • When to use: the first or second session of anger management, before skills
  • Who fills it in: the client, with you in session, or at home for the life areas if the hour ends early
  • Based on: SAMHSA’s 2019 anger management manual for CBT groups (anger felt too intensely, too often or expressed badly, and its payoffs and consequences), with decisional balance from SAMHSA’s TIP 35
  • Ratings: how often and how long (four choices each), how strong on a 1 to 10 scale, eight life areas from Not at all to Very much, and how important change is from 0 to 10
  • Life areas: people close to me, friends and free time, work or school, my body, my mood and how I see myself, alcohol or drugs, money and the law, and safety
  • Format: fillable PDF and Word (.docx), US Letter

What’s in the When Is Anger a Problem? Self-Assessment

The ratings of how often, how strong and how long come before any area of life. That keeps the pattern of the client’s anger in view on its own. The eight areas then turn the pattern into costs the client can point to, and the last page weighs those costs against what anger gets them and closes on their own reasons to change. Here’s each part and what the client marks in it.

PartWhat the client rates or writes
1. How often, how strong, how longHow often they got angry in the past month, how strong it usually gets and its peak on a 1 to 10 scale, and how long it lasts or stays on their mind
2. How my anger comes outThe ways it shows, ticked in three columns, Out loud, Held in and Sideways, each with an Other line
3. Where anger causes problemsA rating from Not at all to Very much for each of eight areas, and what has happened in each
4. What anger gets me, and what it costs meWhat anger gets them in the moment, beside what it costs over time
5. Reasons to changeWhat would be better, how important change is from 0 to 10, where to start, and one small step with the next session date

Working Through the Self-Assessment

Pages 1 to 3 draw the picture, and page 4 points it toward change. Keep that order, and save the last page for the end of the hour. In the parts below, Ruel Whitt, a fictional HVAC technician whose employer sent him after he shouted at a customer, works through it in his first session.

How Often, How Strong, How Long

Below your practice header, page 1 starts with how often anger comes, how strong it gets and how long it lasts, each rated for the past month.

Page 1 of the anger self-assessment with the how often, how strong and how long ratings outlined for the example client
How often, how strong and how long Ruel’s anger runs.
  1. How often. Ruel marked A few times a week, one step below Most days.
  2. How strong. How strong anger usually gets and the strongest it got this month, both on the 1 to 10 scale. His usual is 7, and his strongest was 9.
  3. How long it lasts. From A few minutes to Days, counting the time anger stays on the client’s mind. For Ruel, it’s most of the day.

Tip: The 1 to 10 scale matches the one in the Coping Skills for Anger worksheet. A client who moves on to skills keeps the numbers they already know.

How Anger Comes Out

Under the ratings, the client ticks the ways their anger shows, and stewing and sarcasm count beside shouting.

The three columns of how anger comes out on the anger self-assessment, with the Held in column and an Other line outlined
Ruel’s ticks in the three columns.
  1. Held in. The quieter ways, from stewing for hours to pulling away from people. Ruel ticked stewing for hours and shutting down.
  2. Other. A line under each column for a way the list doesn’t name. Under Out loud, Ruel added punching the wall.

Where Anger Causes Problems

Pages 2 and 3 take the cost one area at a time, each rated from Not at all to Very much with a box for what has happened.

Two life areas on page 2 of the anger self-assessment, people close to me and work or school, outlined with their ratings
People close to Ruel, and his work.
  1. People close to me. Partner, children and family. Ruel rated it A lot. His wife, Gaylene, says she walks on eggshells, and his daughter goes to her room when his truck pulls in.
  2. Work or school. Arguments, warnings, trouble focusing and lost jobs. Ruel’s one Very much is here, for the written warning after he shouted at a customer.

On page 3 come the last four areas, ending on Safety.

Page 3 of the anger self-assessment with the money and the law area and the safety area outlined for the example client
Money and the law, and Safety.
  1. Money and the law. Damage, fines, lost pay, arrests or court. Ruel’s A little covers $280 of garage drywall he punched through, and a speeding ticket.
  2. Safety. Someone hurt, threatened or afraid, the client included, with a line asking them to tell you that day if anyone has been hurt or threatened, or could be. Ruel wrote that Gaylene gets scared when he tailgates with her in the truck.

The four areas between these are Friends and free time, My body, My mood and how I see myself and Alcohol, drugs or other ways I numb it.

Costs and Reasons to Change

Page 4 sets what anger gets the client in the moment beside what it costs over time, then turns to change.

Page 4 of the anger self-assessment with what anger costs, the importance rating and the small step outlined
Ruel’s costs, how much change matters to him, and his first step.
  1. What it costs me, over time. The box beside what anger gets the client. Ruel listed the warning and maybe his job and pension, his daughter keeping away, headaches and bad sleep, and Gaylene no longer trusting his driving.
  2. How important change is. A rating from 0, not important, to 10, the most important. Ruel chose 8.
  3. One small step before the next session. With the date of that session. When a customer starts arguing, Ruel will say he’ll check with the office and step out to the van for five minutes.

Above the rating, the client writes what would be better if anger caused fewer problems, and below it, where they’d like to start. Ruel starts at work, with the calls where a customer argues about the bill.

Running It in Session

  1. For a client sent by someone else, say who referred them, and that the ratings are theirs to make.
  2. Ask about the highest ratings first, and let the client tell what happened in their own words.
  3. Keep the payoffs brief. Acknowledge what anger gets the client, then spend the time on the costs and the reasons to change.
  4. Ask what keeps the importance rating from being lower.
  5. Turn the starting area and the step into the next session’s plan, and keep the copy to set beside a fresh one at the end of treatment.

The Research Behind the Ratings

SAMHSA’s anger management manual, a CBT group program updated in 2019, says anger becomes a problem when it is felt too intensely, felt too often or expressed inappropriately, and lists consequences from lost jobs and arrests to guilt, shame and regret. It calls the short-term gains of an outburst “apparent” payoffs, because the long-term costs outweigh them. SAMHSA’s TIP 35 calls weighing both sides decisional balance, links it with more motivation to change, and advises giving the client’s reasons for change more time than their reasons to carry on.

What It Can and Can’t Do

The ratings show where anger costs a client most. They aren’t a diagnosis or a risk assessment, and there’s no total or cut-off. When outbursts are frequent or out of proportion, a brief screen such as the five-item DAR-5 can show whether a fuller assessment would help. A Safety rating above Not at all, or any threat of harm, calls for a safety conversation that day. A filled copy names a partner, children and an employer, and records damage and trouble with the law. Agree with the client where it will be kept.

Make It Yours

  • For the skills that come next, the Coping Skills for Anger worksheet picks up from the client’s starting area with warning signs, a time-out and a practice log.
  • To log each outburst as it happens, use the Anger Diary Worksheet, with triggers, warning signs and a week review.
  • When the Held in column fills up, the Anger Iceberg Worksheet looks at the hurt or fear under the anger.
  • In Word, rename an area to fit the client, such as caregiving or driving, and change the paper to A4 under Layout if you print outside the US.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is anger ever healthy?

Yes. APA calls anger “a completely normal, usually healthy, human emotion”, and Mind notes it can help people stand against injustice. The lead line on page 1 starts there, calling anger a normal emotion before it names when anger becomes a problem.

Is yelling a problem if I never hit anyone?

It can be. SAMHSA notes that verbal abuse and threats, even without violence, lead others to develop fear, resentment and a lack of trust. The Out loud column lists yelling and threats beside hitting for that reason.

Can anger affect physical health?

A review of 44 studies by Chida and Steptoe linked anger and hostility with more heart disease in healthy people and a poorer outlook in people who already had it. My body, on page 2, asks about sleep, headaches, tension and blood pressure.

Is this a test for anger problems?

No. It has no score or cut-off. APA notes that psychological tests measure angry feelings and how well someone handles them, and that if someone has a problem with anger, chances are good they already know it.

When should someone get professional help for anger?

NHS advice is to see a doctor when someone is struggling to cope with anger, when what they’re doing to help themselves isn’t working, or when they’re acting in an abusive or violent way.

Sources