Some automatic thoughts sound like a verdict already handed down, such as “I’m bad at my job” or “I always let people down”. Using this thoughts on trial worksheet, you and the client treat a thought like that as a charge. The prosecution argues it, the client takes the defense, and both sides have to stick to facts someone else could check.
Evidence that breaks the rules on either side is struck, including a feeling dressed up as proof or a reassurance with nothing behind it. Each side then answers the other once, and the client weighs what’s left as the judge. The verdict can find the charge proven in part, and when it does, the client leaves with a step to deal with the part that’s true.
Thoughts on Trial Worksheet: Evidence and a Fair Verdict
At a glance
- When to use: in CBT once the client can catch an automatic thought, for a sticky thought of guilt, shame or self-criticism
- Ages: adults and older teens
- Who fills it in: the client, with you ruling on the evidence the first time; later trials as homework
- Time: about 15 to 20 minutes for a first trial in session
- Ratings: belief in the charge and the strength of each feeling, 0 to 100, before and after; belief in the verdict
- Verdicts: not proven, proven in part or proven, with a step when any part is proven
- Based on: the courtroom frame of trial-based cognitive therapy, and examining the evidence in CBT
- Format: fillable PDF and Word (.docx), US Letter, 4 pages
What’s in the Thoughts on Trial Worksheet
The client reads the rules of evidence before writing anything and knows what counts and what doesn’t. The same rules apply to both sides. The trial itself has room for each side’s evidence, a tick to strike what breaks the rules, and a second round where the “yes, but” gets said out loud and answered. In the verdict, the client keeps the true part of the charge instead of arguing it away. On your own page are notes on how to run it, where it comes from and what to watch for. The table shows who uses each part, and when.
| Part | Page | Who uses it, and when |
|---|---|---|
| Rules of evidence and the case | 1 | The client, with you, at the start |
| The Trial, with both sides’ replies | 2 | The client, with you ruling on each piece of evidence |
| The Verdict, and a step if the charge is proven | 3 | The client, at the end of the session or at home |
| For the Therapist | 4 | You, before the first trial |
Using the Thoughts on Trial Worksheet
The client writes the charge and rates it on page 1, weighs it on page 2 and rates it again on page 3. Each trial ends with a measure of how far the charge moved. Let’s follow one trial through, the one Ladonna Bixby, a fictional dental office billing coordinator, held over a claims report her manager sent back.
The Rules and the Case
Clients often list feelings as evidence, and they can be just as quick to list comforting lines that nobody could check. Before writing any evidence, the client reads in the rules box that neither counts. Then they write the case, pinning down exactly what’s on trial.

- Rules of evidence. Admissible means something that happened that others could check, words someone actually said or wrote, or a record. Not admissible means feelings, guesses about what someone thinks, predictions or labels, and reassurance. A one-line test asks whether someone who wasn’t there could check it.
- The charge. The thought, word for word, written as a statement. Ladonna’s is “I’m bad at my job, and Corwin knows it”, from the day her manager, Corwin, sent back her report with eight corrections.
- How strongly I believe it, and What I feel. Belief from 0 to 100 and a word for each feeling with its own 0 to 100. She started at 85, ashamed 80 and anxious 70.
The Trial
On page 2, each side has evidence boxes with a Struck tick beside each one. You and the client rule on the evidence together once both sides have made their case.

- Prosecution, the charge is true. The eight corrections and Corwin’s note are admitted. “I feel like a fraud” is struck as a feeling, and “He must think I can’t handle the new billing codes” as a guess.
- Defense, the charge is not proven. Two good reviews, six corrections from codes that changed on October 1, and being asked to train the new hire are all admitted. “Everyone at work loves me” is struck as reassurance.
- Prosecution’s reply and Defense’s reply. The prosecution’s “yes, but” is that two corrections were plain typos. The defense answers with facts only, two typos in a 40-claim report and a code list that reached the billing team after she’d sent the report in.
The Verdict
On page 3, the client answers the judge’s questions, then reaches a verdict, rates the charge again and plans a step for whatever part of it holds up.

- The judge’s questions. Is every word of the charge proven, including words like always, never or everyone? Is there another explanation that fits the evidence still standing? Would the client find a friend guilty on this evidence? What do the facts actually prove? Ladonna’s answer to the first is that only the mistakes on this one report are proven.
- Verdict, The verdict in my words, and the ratings. She chose proven in part and wrote “I made mistakes on this report, mostly from the new codes, and I have a record of doing this job well.” Her belief in the charge fell from 85 to 30, she believes the verdict at 75, and the shame came down from 80 to 35.
- If the charge is proven, in whole or in part. What the client can do about it, when, and a line to remember if the charge comes back that week. Ladonna will ask Corwin for 30 minutes on the new codes on Thursday 10/21 and read each report aloud before sending it.
Running It in Session
- Teach the rules first. Read the rules box together and practice on one example of each kind of evidence that isn’t admissible.
- Write the charge word for word. Keep it as the client said it, then take the starting ratings.
- Rule on the evidence together. Act as the clerk of the court. Strike what breaks the rules on both sides, and bring in facts the client left out.
- Give the “yes, but” its say. Let the prosecution’s reply be as strong as the client feels it, then work on the defense’s answer.
- Turn a proven part into a step. When any part of the charge holds up, move to problem solving instead of arguing with the facts.
The Idea Behind It
Trial-based cognitive therapy, developed by Irismar de Oliveira, starts from the idea that clients accuse and sentence themselves without ever mounting their own defense. The client plays the prosecutor, the defense attorney and the jury in turn. This worksheet borrows that courtroom frame and keeps the rule common to CBT thought records, which is to weigh facts, not opinions or feelings.
In a 2008 study of the trial-based thought record, belief and emotion dropped after the defense’s pleas, with a further drop between the first and second pleas. The second round on page 2 follows that finding. A 2023 review found 10 randomized trials, in social anxiety, depression, PTSD and OCD. In the 5 it could pool, trial-based cognitive therapy did about as well as other first-choice psychotherapies, and its authors call for more rigorous studies.
What It Can and Can’t Do
A single trial can loosen a thought, and the 2008 study’s authors describe the change as possibly temporary. A thought that keeps coming back across several trials may rest on a core belief, which calls for slower work, and so does a charge about trauma. Leave the trial for later with a client in crisis. The help lines, 988 and 911, are printed at the foot of every client page. The charge and the evidence can be painful to read later. Agree with the client on where the filled copy is kept.
Make It Yours
- For a “what if” charge about the future, test the prediction with the Behavioral Experiment Worksheet instead of putting it on trial.
- When the same charge keeps returning, move to the Core Belief Evidence Worksheet.
- For a client who mixes up facts and opinions, practice with the Fact or Opinion Worksheet before the first trial.
- In Word, add your own examples to the rules box, such as a text message or a school report.
Frequently Asked Questions
When the thought is the charge, the client argues the defense, the side they rarely take. On page 2, that means writing the facts that answer the charge, then replying once more to the prosecution’s “yes, but”.
Strike it, and point back to the rules box on page 1. A feeling such as “I feel like a fraud” tells you how the charge feels, and the trial is about whether it’s true. Ladonna’s example strikes one feeling and one guess on the prosecution side.
The verdict can find it proven in part or proven. Then the client writes what they can do about it and when, instead of arguing with the facts, as Ladonna did with her plan to learn the new codes.
The same rules apply to both sides. “Everyone loves me” is no easier to check than “they all think I’m useless”, and a verdict built on it won’t hold up the next time the charge comes back.
That’s common at first. The Centre for Clinical Interventions describes people who see a balanced thought is fair but aren’t convinced yet, and suggests repeating it and acting on it. The ratings on page 3 and the next trial show whether belief catches up.
Sources
- Delavechia, T. R., et al. (2016). Changing negative core beliefs with trial-based thought record. Archives of Clinical Psychiatry
- de Oliveira, I. R. (2008). Trial-Based Thought Record (TBTR): preliminary data on a strategy to deal with core beliefs by combining sentence reversion and the use of analogy with a judicial process. Revista Brasileira de Psiquiatria
- Hemanny, C., et al. (2023). Trial-Based Cognitive Therapy for depressive and anxious symptoms: A systematic review and meta-analysis of efficacy and dropout rates. Journal of Mood and Anxiety Disorders
- Back from the Bluez, Module 7. Centre for Clinical Interventions, Government of Western Australia
- Cognitive Restructuring. East London NHS Foundation Trust
- 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline



