Silver Linings Worksheet (PDF): Guided Reframe and 3-Week Practice Log

This silver linings worksheet is for a client who dwells on what goes wrong. It’s a short daily optimism practice, with a guided page to learn it on and a log to keep it going.

Each time, the client rates how upset they are before and after finding the silver linings. Read across the log, those two numbers tell you and the client whether the practice is easing the upset.

Silver Linings Worksheet: Guided Page and 3-Week Log

Silver linings worksheet guided page with five good things, a frustrating moment, a change question and three silver linings
Silver linings worksheet practice log for days 1 to 14 with a good thing, a setback, a silver lining and upset ratings
Silver linings worksheet practice log for days 15 to 21, then Looking back after three weeks with a choice of how to go on
Download

At a glance

  • When to use: with a client who dwells on setbacks or leans pessimistic
  • Approach: the silver linings exercise, tested with a goal visualization in Sergeant and Mongrain’s 2014 optimism study, and a question about change from Troy, Shallcross and Mauss (2013)
  • Who fills it in: the client, with you for the guided page in session, then at home
  • Timing: about ten minutes a day for three weeks, then Looking back at the session after day 21
  • Parts: a guided page for one frustrating moment, a practice log for days 1 to 21, and Looking back
  • Format: fillable PDF

What’s in the Practice

On the guided page, the client does the full exercise, and it’s there again for any day that needs more room. On the log, the client goes through the guided page’s steps again in a few words a day.

PartWhat the client writes
Five good things right nowWhat makes life good at the moment, big or small
What didn’t go my wayThe most recent frustrating moment, how it felt, and how upset they are, 0 to 10
Can I change any of it?Yes, Partly or No, and what they’ll do about it if they can
Three silver liningsThree silver linings, and how upset they are now
Practice LogFor each day, a good thing, what didn’t go their way, the silver linings, and the upset before and after
Looking back after three weeksWhat they notice now, their proudest silver lining, a day they could have acted, and how to go on

Working Through the Practice

You and the client do the guided page once together in session. The client then fills in a row of the log every day for three weeks, and you go through Looking back together at the session after day 21. Floyd Barnhart, a bus mechanic, wrote his guided page about missing his granddaughter’s last softball game when his shift ran two hours late. His first answers are about what’s going right.

Good Things First

Silver linings worksheet with the opening line about the hard part and the good things right now highlighted
The opening line and the good things, filled in with an example.
  1. The line at the top. A silver lining doesn’t mean the hard part didn’t matter, and for a loss or a trauma, the client talks it over with you first.
  2. Five good things right now. Anything from health to this morning’s coffee. Floyd started with his granddaughter Kenzie, coffee on the back porch, and his bowling league.

The Moment and How It Felt

Silver linings worksheet with what happened, how it felt and how upset the client is highlighted
What didn’t go my way, filled in with an example.
  1. What happened. The most recent time something didn’t go the client’s way. “My shift ran two hours late and I missed Kenzie’s last softball game of the season.”
  2. How it felt. The feeling itself, in the client’s words. Floyd was frustrated with the schedule, and guilty because he’d told her he’d be there.
  3. How upset am I? From 0, not at all, to 10, the most. He chose 7.

Can Any of It Change?

After Yes, Partly or No, there’s room for what the client will do about it when the answer is Yes or Partly. That way, the client plans for the part they can change before looking for anything good in it. Floyd marked Partly, and plans to ask his supervisor on Monday for game days off, two weeks ahead.

Silver linings worksheet with the Can I change any of it question and what the client will do about it highlighted
Can I change any of it, filled in with an example.

Three Silver Linings

Silver linings worksheet with the three silver linings and the second upset rating highlighted
Three silver linings, filled in with an example.
  1. Silver lining 1, 2 and 3. The hint suggests something good that came of it, a lesson, or how it’ll look in a year. Floyd’s overtime covers most of the furnace repair, his daughter Rae sent a video of the game, and the evening showed him he has to speak up about his schedule.
  2. How upset am I now? The same 0 to 10 scale as before. His 7 came down to 4.

Every Day on the Log

Silver linings worksheet practice log with the note above the table and the before and after column highlighted
The practice log, filled in with an example.
  1. The note above the log. Each row is the short daily version of the guided page, a good thing, a moment that didn’t go the client’s way and its silver linings, and the guided page is there for the full practice.
  2. Before / after. How upset the client was on that day, 0 to 10, before and after the silver linings. He rated 6 before and 4 after on his opening day, and 3 and 1 by day 19.

Looking Back

Silver linings worksheet Looking back with what the client notices, a day they could have acted and how to go on
Looking back after three weeks, filled in with an example.
  1. What I notice now when something goes wrong. “I still get sore about things, but I come down faster.”
  2. A day I could have done something about it, and what I did. For Floyd, it was the supervisor’s maybe, when he wanted to call it a lesson and leave it.
  3. From here. Keep going daily, A few times a week, or Stop for now. He chose a few times a week.

He named the spring games as the silver lining he’s proudest of, because asking was the thing he could do.

Teaching It and Reading It Back

  1. Choose a recent, everyday frustration for the guided page, something small enough to work through in one sitting.
  2. Let the feeling stand before anything good is named. Ask about “How it felt” first.
  3. When the answer is Yes or Partly, agree on what the client will do before the client moves on to silver linings.
  4. Show the log, and agree on a time of day that suits the client’s routine.
  5. At Looking back, read the before and after numbers together first, then the client’s answers.

Where the Silver Linings Worksheet Comes From

In Susan Sergeant and Myriam Mongrain’s 2014 study of 466 adults, the optimism group did silver linings and a goal visualization exercise online every day for three weeks. Compared with a control group who wrote about daily activities, the two exercises together reduced dysfunctional attitudes, and pessimistic participants reported fewer depressive symptoms. “Can I change any of it?” comes from Allison Troy, Amanda Shallcross and Iris Mauss, who found in 2013 that reappraisal may help with stress a person can’t control and hurt when they could change the situation.

Changing It for a Client

  • When the hard moment comes with a harsh thought about themselves, the client can work on the thought with the Cognitive Reframing Worksheet.
  • When a setback feels like proof the client can’t change, they can work that moment through to a new strategy and a dated step on the Growth Mindset Worksheet.

Frequently Asked Questions

Isn’t this a form of toxic positivity?

The line at the top says a silver lining doesn’t mean the hard part didn’t matter. Berkeley’s Greater Good in Education guide asks teachers to keep the practice from becoming “an invalidation of their emotional responses”, and “How it felt” is there for that.

What if the client can’t find a silver lining?

The hint suggests something good that came of it, a lesson, or how it’ll look in a year. On the log, the column is “Silver lining(s)”, and one is enough on a hard day.

How long should the client keep it up?

Three weeks, as in the study. Greater Good in Action notes that the effects seemed to wear off two months later, and suggests repeating the practice from time to time, which is what A few times a week in “From here” is for.

Sources