Inner Critic Worksheet (Fillable PDF): Coach Responses and Self-Talk Log

This inner critic worksheet is for therapists working on a client’s self-criticism, alongside low self-esteem, perfectionism or shame. The client can write down what their inner critic said in one hard moment and reply to each line in the voice of a coach who is honest and still kind.

Between sessions, the client can keep a short log of the times the critic speaks up, with the coach’s answer beside each one. When they bring it back, you’ll both see which situations set the critic off and what changes when the coach answers.

Inner Critic Worksheet: Critic and Coach, Self-Talk Log

Inner critic worksheet with a hard moment, the coach's voice and three critic bubbles each answered by a coach bubble
Self-talk log with columns for the date, what happened, what the critic said and the coach's answer, and a look back
Download

At a glance

  • When to use: once self-criticism is a goal of treatment, in CBT or compassion-focused work
  • Who fills it in: the client with you in session, then the client alone through the week
  • In session: a hard moment, who the coach sounds like, the critic’s lines with the coach’s answers, the tone of each voice and a next step
  • Between sessions: a self-talk log with the date, what happened, what the critic said and the coach’s answer
  • Review: when the critic shows up most, whose voice it sounds like and what changes with the coach
  • Format: fillable PDF

What’s included in the inner critic worksheet

In session, the client works through a hard moment slowly, with you beside them. Through the week ahead, the critic speaks up without warning, and the log is there for those moments. Each part asks the client a different question about the same harsh voice.

PartWhat the client works out
A time I was hard on myselfWhich moment to work on
My coach sounds likeWhose kind, honest voice to borrow
What my critic says, and how my coach answersWhat the critic said, and the answer to each line
How each voice soundsThe tone behind the words
One thing my coach would have me do nextA small step forward
Self-Talk LogWhen the critic shows up during the week
Looking backThe patterns to talk through at the next session

How the Inner Critic Worksheet Works

The worksheet holds a conversation between two voices about a hard moment. The client picks a coach, writes down the critic’s harsh lines, then answers each one in the coach’s voice, and the tone and next step come after. The log takes that same answer into the week, and at the next session, the look-back sums up the week. We’ll go part by part with Rhonda Kessler, a mom who’s been hard on herself since she missed her son’s field trip form.

The Hard Moment and the Coach

The worksheet opens on what happened and on the voice the client will answer with.

Inner critic worksheet with the hard moment and the person the coach sounds like highlighted, both filled in
The hard moment and the coach, filled in with an example.
  1. A time I was hard on myself. A few lines on one recent moment, in plain facts. Rhonda wrote that she forgot to send back the permission form for her son’s field trip, and he was the only one in his class who couldn’t go.
  2. My coach sounds like. Someone kind and honest, real or imagined, whose voice the client can borrow. Rhonda chose Mrs. Tolliver, her high school softball coach, “Firm, fair and never cruel.”

What the Critic Says and the Coach Answers

Each critic line has the coach’s answer beside it, joined by an arrow. With the two side by side, the client replies to every harsh line.

Inner critic worksheet with three critic bubbles and three coach bubbles highlighted, each critic line answered on its row
The critic’s lines and the coach’s answers, filled in with an example.
  1. My critic. The critic’s words, exactly as the client hears them. Rhonda’s critic said “You can’t even keep track of one form. What kind of mother are you?” and “You always let him down.”
  2. My coach. The answer to the line on the same row, honest about what went wrong and kind about it. To “You always let him down,” Rhonda’s coach answered “Always isn’t true. You’ve been at every one of his games this fall.”

Tone and the Next Step

The next fields name how each voice sounds, then turn the coach’s answer into something to do.

Inner critic worksheet with the critic's tone, the coach's tone and the next step highlighted, each filled in
The tone of each voice and the next step, filled in with an example.
  1. My critic’s tone. How the critic sounds. For Rhonda, “Cold and sharp, like it wants me to feel small.”
  2. My coach’s tone. How the coach sounds. Rhonda’s is “Warm and steady, like Mrs. Tolliver.”
  3. “One thing my coach would have me do next.” A small, practical step, never a punishment. Rhonda’s coach would have her keep a folder for school forms by the door and check it with her son every Sunday night.

The Self-Talk Log

Each row of the log is a moment from the week, starting with its date. The client can fill in a row soon after the critic speaks up, while the words are fresh.

Self-talk log with what happened, what the critic said and the coach's answer highlighted for three filled entries
The Self-Talk Log, filled in with an example.
  1. What happened. The situation in a few words. On 10/19, Rhonda’s manager found an error in a patient chart.
  2. My critic said. The critic’s words that day, “You’re careless. You’ll get fired.”
  3. My coach answers. The reply in the coach’s voice, “One error, caught early. I fixed it in five minutes and told her how.”

Looking Back at the Next Session

Under the log, the client sums up the week’s entries in a few words, ready to talk through together.

Looking back boxes with when the critic shows up most, whose voice it sounds like and what changes with the coach highlighted
Looking back, filled in with an example.
  1. When my critic shows up most. The pattern across the week’s rows. Rhonda’s critic shows up when she’s tired and rushing, and about anything to do with being a mom.
  2. Whose voice it sounds like. Someone the critic echoes, if the client recognizes one. For Rhonda, it’s her grandmother checking her chores when she was a kid.
  3. What changes with my coach. What answering does for the client. Rhonda calms down faster and fixes the problem instead of replaying it all night.

Use It in Session

Most of a first session goes to the hard moment and the critic and coach lines, and later sessions start from the log. A few ways to run it:

  1. Find the coach first. Picture the person together, their face and their tone of voice, before writing any of the critic’s lines.
  2. Write the critic’s words as they come. Ask for the exact words, harsh as they are, the way the client hears them.
  3. Read both columns aloud. Then ask the client how each voice sounded, and write it under How each voice sounds.
  4. Agree on the log before the client leaves. An entry after each hard moment is enough, and a few words in each column will do.
  5. Start the next session with the look-back. Fill it in together from the week’s rows, then pick the next moment to work on.

Compassion-Focused Therapy and Self-Kindness

In his introduction to compassion-focused therapy, Paul Gilbert describes clients with high shame and self-criticism using “a cold, bullying or aggressive inner tone” to try to change, and therapists helping them hear alternative thoughts as kind and supportive. Kristin Neff’s work on self-compassion describes self-kindness as being understanding toward yourself in pain or failure, instead of harshly self-critical. On the worksheet, the client replies to each critic line in a kind, honest voice, names the tone of both voices, and ends on one small step.

Using the Inner Critic Worksheet Well

A copy holds one moment and one week of the log. Here are its limits and some ways to adapt it.

What It Can and Can’t Do

The worksheet records the self-talk and the client’s answers, and the work of changing it happens in therapy.

A filled copy records the client’s harshest words about themselves, and sometimes the person those words echo. If the client keeps the log at home or on their phone, talk about who else might see it.

Make It Yours

  • Start with the log. For a client who struggles to recall a moment, a week of entries can show which one to work on first.
  • Work through a second moment. A fresh copy for a moment in another part of life, such as work or a friendship, shows if the critic says the same things there.
  • Keep the coach the same. Write the same coach’s name on every new copy. The voice grows familiar with use.
  • Add your practice details. The practice name, contact line and therapist fields are editable at the top.

Frequently Asked Questions

Where does a client’s inner critic come from?

Gilbert writes that shame and self-criticism are often rooted in histories of abuse, bullying, high expressed emotion in the family, neglect or lack of affection. The look-back asks only whose voice the critic sounds like, which the client can leave blank.

Won’t a kind inner voice let the client off the hook?

Neff argues that self-compassion doesn’t mean passivity, and that a lack of it is more likely to lead there. Gilbert notes that encouraging means giving courage. The coach on this worksheet is honest about what went wrong and ends on a step to take next.

What if the client can’t think of anyone kind to be the coach?

The coach can be imagined. In compassion-focused therapy, clients picture a compassionate other, down to the face and tone of voice, and that image can fill the coach’s line just as well as a real person.

Sources