Four Horsemen Worksheet (PDF, Word): Antidotes, Break Plan and Conflict Log

Once a couple learns the four horsemen, each partner tends to spot them first in the other. With this four horsemen worksheet, each partner turns the list on themselves. They find the horseman they reach for, say the same point again with its antidote, and keep a week’s record of how their own arguments went.

The first page is a handout for the session where you teach Gottman’s four patterns of criticism, contempt, defensiveness and stonewalling, with a line showing how each one sounds and how its antidote sounds instead. Each partner fills in the pages after it on their own copy, and with the flooding plan, the couple have a way to stop an argument that is going badly without it feeling like a door slammed.

Four Horsemen Worksheet: Antidotes, Break Plan, Log

Four horsemen worksheet first page with criticism, contempt, defensiveness and stonewalling beside their antidotes
My Horsemen page of the four horsemen worksheet with how often each is used, what it sounds like and what sets it off
Antidote Practice page with four horseman lines to answer with the antidote, and One of Mine boxes
When I'm Flooded page with signs to tick, rules for taking a break and a break plan with a signal and a return time
Blank conflict log for a week, with the main horseman, flooded, the antidote tried and how it ended
Therapist's Notes page for the four horsemen worksheet, with safety first, teaching, practice and reading the log
Download

At a glance

  • When to use: early in Gottman Method couples work, then as homework over the following weeks
  • Who fills it in: you teach page 1 to both partners; each partner fills in their own pages 2 to 5, and the couple agree the break plan together
  • The four pairs: criticism and gentle startup, contempt and appreciation and respect, defensiveness and taking responsibility, stonewalling and self-soothing
  • My Horsemen: how often the client uses each one (rarely, sometimes or often), what it sounds like, what sets it off, and the one to work on first
  • Break plan: flooding signs, a signal both agree on, what calms each partner, and a time to come back
  • Conflict Log: a row for each disagreement in a week, then a look back at the hardest one
  • Format: fillable PDF, and an editable Word version (.docx)

What’s in the Four Horsemen Worksheet

Couples tend to arrive knowing these patterns as accusations. Here each partner works only on their own patterns, such as which horseman shows up when they argue, what it sounds like when they say it, and what to say instead. The break plan matters most for stonewalling, which Gottman ties to being flooded, and the log tells you whether any of it carried into the week. Each part, and who uses it:

PartWho fills it inWhat it holds
The four horsemen and their antidotes (page 1)You teach it to both partnersEach horseman and its antidote, a “sounds like” line for both, and a safety line
My Horsemen (page 2)Each partner, on their own copyHow often they use each horseman, what it sounds like, what sets it off, and the one to work on first
Antidote Practice (page 3)Each partner, aloud with the otherHorseman lines to say again with the antidote, and one of their own
When I’m Flooded (page 4)Each partner, with the signal and return time agreed togetherBody signs, the rules for a break, the signal, what calms them, and when they’ll come back
Conflict Log (page 5)Each partner, over a weekEach disagreement, the main horseman, whether they were flooded, the antidote tried, how it ended, and a look back
Therapist’s Notes (page 6)YouSafety first, teaching page 1, practice and flooding, reading the log, session notes

How the Four Horsemen Worksheet Works

After you teach page 1, nothing on the later pages asks about the other partner. On page 2 the client finds their go-to horseman, and on page 3 they practice the words for its antidote. Page 4 is for the moments when they’re too flooded for words, and in the log they record how the week went. Dorinda Prentiss, a made-up client married to Rusty, learned the horsemen and their antidotes with him in session and then chose criticism as her own horseman to work on first.

The Four Horsemen and Their Antidotes

Read across each row, with the horseman on the left, its antidote on the right, and a line for how each one sounds.

Four horsemen worksheet handout with the contempt row, the stonewalling row and the safety line outlined in red
The four horsemen and their antidotes.
  1. Contempt, and Appreciation and Respect. Contempt is speaking from above, with mockery, sarcasm, name-calling or eye-rolling. Its antidote has two halves. In the moment, the partner describes their own feelings and needs, not the other person. Over time, they notice and say what their partner does right.
  2. Stonewalling and Self-Soothing. Stonewalling is shutting down when flooded, going quiet or leaving without a word. The antidote is to notice the flooding, ask for a break, calm down and come back.
  3. The safety line. Partners use the worksheet only if both feel safe. Anyone living with fear, threats, control or violence is asked to tell the therapist on their own.

My Horsemen

Page 2 opens by saying the horsemen are for catching yourself, never for naming what a partner does in a fight.

Four horsemen worksheet My Horsemen page with the criticism block and The One I'll Work On First outlined, filled in
My Horsemen, filled in with an example.
  1. Criticism. Dorinda marks it Often. Hers sounds like “You never plan anything. I have to think of everything in this house,” and it comes after a long shift, when she has held it in all day. Every horseman on the page has the same rating and boxes.
  2. The One I’ll Work On First. A drop-down for one horseman, and a box for its antidote in the client’s own words. Dorinda chose criticism, and wrote that she’ll start with how she feels about what bothered her, then ask for what she needs.

Antidote Practice

One partner reads a horseman line aloud, and the other says the same thing again, using its antidote. Then both write their answers.

Four horsemen worksheet Antidote Practice with the contempt practice row and One of Mine boxes outlined, with answers
Antidote Practice, filled in with an example.
  1. Contempt. The line is “Wow, you remembered my birthday. Do you want a medal?” Dorinda’s antidote says she felt hurt that her birthday almost slipped by, and thanks him for the dinner.
  2. One of Mine. A horseman the client used recently, and what they could say instead. Dorinda’s “You never plan anything for us” becomes a request for one date night this month.

When I’m Flooded

The page explains flooding as the body going into alarm, which makes it hard to listen. Each partner ticks their own signs, and the couple agree the signal and the return time together.

Four horsemen worksheet When I'm Flooded page with My Signs, Taking a Break and My Break Plan outlined, filled in
When I’m Flooded, filled in with an example.
  1. My Signs. Six signs to tick and an Other line. Dorinda ticks a racing heart, not really hearing what Rusty says, and tight muscles.
  2. Taking a Break. Say it instead of walking out, and give a time to come back. Take at least 20 minutes, do something soothing instead of replaying the argument, and come back within 24 hours at the time you set.
  3. My Break Plan. Dorinda’s signal is “Time out, I’ll be back at” and a time. To calm down, she’ll breathe slowly, walk outside, take a shower or sit on the porch with the dog, and they come back within the hour at the kitchen table.

Conflict Log

Each partner fills in a row after each disagreement in the week, keeping the ones that mattered most if there are more than six.

Four horsemen worksheet Conflict Log with four filled rows and the look back at the hardest one outlined in red
The Conflict Log, filled in with an example.
  1. The rows. Each has the date, what the disagreement was about, the main horseman (or None), Flooded? as Yes or No, the antidote or repair tried, and how it ended, as Calm, Mixed or Tense. On Wednesday, after a long shift, Dorinda criticized, got flooded, called a time-out and walked the dog for 25 minutes. That one ended Mixed.
  2. Looking back on the hardest one. Filled in once both partners are calm. In My part in it, Dorinda wrote that she started with “you never” before she’d put her bag down, and next time she’ll eat and change first.

Therapist’s Notes

Page 6 is for you. It covers teaching the handout row by row, running the practice aloud, and reading the logs for the couple’s cycle, such as criticism met with defensiveness, with a box for session notes at the end.

Using It With a Couple

  1. Before page 1, meet each partner alone and ask about safety.
  2. Teach page 1 together, reading across each row and saying both example lines aloud.
  3. Hand each partner their own copy of pages 2 to 5. Give them time in the same session to fill in page 2, then ask each to name their own horseman to the other.
  4. Run the practice aloud, swapping who reads the horseman line.
  5. Agree the break plan before they leave, with the signal, the length and where they’ll meet again.
  6. Start the next session from both logs, and coach one antidote at a time.

The Four Horsemen in the Gottman Method

Each antidote on page 1 follows the Gottman Institute, which pairs every one of John Gottman’s four horsemen with the habit that takes its place in an argument. Stonewalling usually comes from being physiologically flooded, and the Institute’s advice is a break of at least 20 minutes, long enough for the body to calm down. Julie Gottman adds that the partner who calls the break says when they’ll come back, at most 24 hours later, so the other doesn’t feel rejected. The look back on the log follows the last steps of the Gottmans’ Aftermath of a Fight, where each partner owns their part and makes a plan for next time.

What It Can and Can’t Do

The worksheet helps partners catch their own patterns. It doesn’t settle what they argue about, and Gottman’s own view is that many conflicts are managed, not resolved. It isn’t for a relationship with battering or one partner afraid of the other. Gottman writes that couples therapy is inappropriate when battery is present. A partner’s log can hold things they haven’t said aloud yet, such as an eye-roll they’re ashamed of, so each copy stays with the person who filled it in until they choose to share it.

Make It Yours

  • When criticism is the couple’s main horseman, go deeper with the Soft Startup Worksheet, which drills the gentle startup and plans one real conversation.
  • For a wider first look at the relationship, each partner can rate its areas, conflict among them, on the Relationship Check-In Worksheet.
  • In the Word version, swap the practice lines on page 3 for this couple’s own arguments, such as money, in-laws or screen time.
  • For a second week, print a fresh page 5 and keep page 4 as it is.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which of the four horsemen is the most harmful?

Contempt. Gottman calls it the single greatest predictor of divorce, which is why its row on page 1 says so, and why its antidote asks for appreciation over time as well as a different line in the moment.

Isn’t taking a break just stonewalling?

Not when the partner says they need a break and when they’ll be back. Julie Gottman suggests “I’m flooded and I need to take a break” rather than “You are flooded,” and naming a return time so the other partner doesn’t feel abandoned. The rules on page 4 say the same.

What if my client’s partner uses the labels against them?

Bring it back to the page. Every page after page 1 is about the person filling it in, and the Therapist’s Notes ask you to name the pattern, not the person. In session, pause when a horseman shows up and ask for the same point again with its antidote.

Are the four horsemen a sign of abuse?

The horsemen show up in ordinary conflict between partners who both feel safe. Contempt can include name-calling, though, and the same patterns can come with fear and control. The Gottmans separate arguments that spin out of control from violence one partner uses to control the other, and write that no treatment has been found that stops the second. When one partner uses the horsemen to frighten or control the other, the safety line on page 1 and seeing each partner alone are there for that case. The National Domestic Violence Hotline is in the help line at the foot of each page.

Sources