Cost-Benefit Analysis Worksheet (PDF, Word): Stay or Change, Roadblocks

Part of a client wants to stop a habit, and part of them keeps going back to it. On this cost-benefit analysis worksheet, the client weighs that habit or way of thinking from both sides. The Centre for Clinical Interventions (CCI) in Western Australia says it is important to weigh up both the positive and the negative consequences, of staying the same and of changing.

The client writes what the habit costs and what it brings, and what changing would bring both ways, then ticks which side weighs more and if they’re ready. On the Weighing It Up page, the client plans another way to meet the same need and what they’ll say and do at each roadblock.

Cost-Benefit Analysis Worksheet: Stay or Change, Roadblocks

Blank cost-benefit analysis worksheet, page 1 with the thought or behavior and four boxes for staying the same and changing
Blank Weighing It Up page of the cost-benefit analysis worksheet with another way, roadblocks and what I learned
Download

At a glance

  • When to use: when part of a client wants to change and part doesn’t, in cognitive restructuring, motivation work, perfectionism, procrastination or substance use
  • Who fills it in: the client, in session with you or as homework once the idea is explained
  • Based on: CCI’s Perfectionism in Perspective and Put Off Procrastinating modules, and the VA’s MISSION-VET decisional balance exercise
  • Format: fillable PDF and Word (.docx), US Letter

What’s in the Cost-Benefit Analysis Worksheet

The client weighs the habit both ways before deciding anything, and writes down what keeps the habit going.

PartPageWhat the client writes
The thought or behavior1The one habit or way of thinking to weigh, marked as a thought or a behavior
If I stay the same1How it hurts me, now and later, and how it helps me
If I change1What will be good and what will be bad, including what they’d have to give up
Which weighs more right now?2The side that weighs more, and if they’re ready to change now
Another way2A way to meet the same need as the habit, at less cost
Roadblocks2Each roadblock, what they’ll tell themselves and what they’ll do
What I learned2What the client noticed by weighing it both ways

Weighing One Habit With a Client

Page 1 has both sides of the decision, and page 2 has the weighing and the plan. Brenda Faulkner is a clinician who rewrites her case notes past midnight until she’s sure there’s no mistake in them. Here is how she weighed that habit, part by part.

If I Stay the Same

At the top of page 1, the client names the habit and what keeping it means.

Cost-benefit analysis worksheet page 1 with Brenda's behavior, how it hurts her and how it helps her outlined
The habit, and what staying the same costs and brings.
  1. The thought or behavior. Brenda wrote that she keeps rewriting her case notes, often past midnight, and marked it a behavior.
  2. How it hurts me. She listed five hours of sleep most nights, notes late anyway, snapping at her partner Monte, and headaches by Thursday.
  3. How it helps me. She wrote that her supervisor has never found a mistake, she feels safe from criticism, and it quiets the worry for a while.

If I Change

Lower on page 1, the client looks ahead to changing.

Page 1 with what will be good and what will be bad if Brenda changes outlined
What changing could bring, both ways.
  1. What will be good. Brenda wrote sleep before 11, weekends of her own, time to see her sister, and maybe less worry over time.
  2. What will be bad. She expects anxiety when she hands in a note she hasn’t checked five times, and maybe a small mistake someone sees.

Weighing It Up

Page 2 weighs the two sides and plans for what could get in the way.

Weighing It Up page with which side weighs more, another way and the first roadblock outlined
The weighing, another way and a roadblock.
  1. Which weighs more right now? Brenda ticked that the costs of staying the same and the good of changing weigh more, and that she’s ready.
  2. Another way. The habit makes Brenda feel safe from criticism. To get that at less cost, she’ll check each note once against the clinic’s checklist and ask her supervisor for feedback once a month.
  3. Roadblocks. For the anxiety after one check, she’ll tell herself it comes down with practice, and set a 20-minute limit per note.

In Session

  1. Ask what the habit does for the client. The VA’s workbook asks us to look honestly at what we’re getting out of a behavior, and then to think of another way to meet the same need.
  2. Accept “not yet”. CCI says that when the reasons to stay the same are winning out for now, change will be harder and the client may not be ready.
  3. Bring How it helps me down to Another way. The need behind the habit is real for the client, and the plan is to meet it at less cost.
  4. Read What I learned together. Ask what surprised the client, and which box was hardest to fill in.

Where the Worksheet Comes From

Weighing costs and benefits is a step in cognitive restructuring, and motivational work uses the same balance under the name decisional balance. CCI’s modules on perfectionism and procrastination weigh staying the same against changing, then work through the roadblocks with self-talk and actions. The VA’s MISSION-VET workbook adds the idea of another way to meet the same need.

What It Can and Can’t Do

The worksheet helps a client see a decision clearly, and the decision stays theirs. No side wins by counting lines. If the habit involves self-harm, heavy drinking or drug use, pair it with a safety or risk assessment. Ask the client before a copy goes into a shared record.

Make It Yours

Frequently Asked Questions

Why weigh both staying the same and changing?

A list of a habit’s costs alone leaves out why the client keeps doing it. CCI’s balance sheets ask for both sides of both choices. With the reasons to stay the same written down, the client can plan for them.

Should the client score each item?

Some versions score each item from 1 to 10 and add them up. The sources behind this worksheet weigh the sides by judgment, and the client ticks which side weighs more right now.

What if the client isn’t ready to change?

Then the reasons to stay the same are winning out for now. CCI suggests giving it more thought and working through the roadblocks. Start with Roadblocks on page 2, then weigh it up again.

Can it be used for a thought as well as a behavior?

Yes. The client writes either one at the top of page 1 and marks which it is. Weighing a thought both ways, and planning for its roadblocks, works the same way as for a habit.

Sources